Updated
“Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades” means that almost doing something doesn’t count as doing it. Picture a basketball rolling around the rim and falling out. “I nearly made it!” the player says. Her brother answers with the saying. The shot was close, but her team gets no points for it.
Here, close means near. Say it with the s sound in dose. And counts means gets credit.
Two friends try the same beanbag toss at a fair. Now change just one thing: the rules.
| What the sign says | Where the bag lands | Does it count? |
|---|---|---|
| “Win a prize if the bag goes through the hole.” | Right beside the hole. | No. The saying fits. Almost winning still leaves you without the prize. |
| “One point for landing on the board. Three for going through the hole.” | In exactly the same spot, on the board. | Yes, one point. The rules give credit for getting close. |
The saying is about the result you were trying for. A runner can miss first place by a step and still set her own best time. If she’s pleased with her progress, telling her that “close only counts” would miss her point.
In the game of horseshoes, players toss horseshoes toward an upright stake. Under the National Horseshoe Pitchers Association’s scoring rules, a shoe that lands near the stake can earn a point even if it doesn’t circle it. That makes horseshoes a real example of close counting. The second half makes the same point with dark humor: an explosion can affect what’s nearby.
You may also hear “Close only counts in horseshoes” or “Almost doesn’t count.” People often use the longer saying to tease a friend who nearly won. It can sound dismissive if someone is genuinely disappointed. “You were one point away” acknowledges how close they came.
Researchers tracing the saying have found two stages in American newspapers. In the American Dialect Society discussion of early examples, Fred Shapiro reports a horseshoes-only version in a Nebraska paper in 1914. Jonathan Lighter identifies the full wording in the Columbus Dispatch on December 31, 1964. Those examples show when the wording was already in print. They leave the person who first said it unknown.
A later example comes from Inside the Rail, a railroad safety newsletter. It uses the saying as a headline above an account of a brake that was almost, but not fully, released. That use is serious: doing nearly all of a job can leave something important unfinished.
A contest that goes down to the wire stays undecided until the very end. Either team might win. Say “close only counts in horseshoes” after you know the result, when someone wants credit for almost winning.
Choose an answer to see why it fits or what clue to look for. You can change your answer.
The sign says, “Guess the exact number of jelly beans to win.” Rosa guesses 99. There are 100. What does her friend mean by “Close only counts in horseshoes”?
At the next table, the sign says, “Closest guess wins.” Nobody guesses closer than Rosa. What happens this time?
Your friend didn’t win her race, but she says, “I finished a minute faster than last time!” Which reply recognizes what matters to her?
