Updated
To “chew the cud” about something is to turn it over in your mind, often slowly or repeatedly. Imagine you’ve seen two apartments. On the bus home you keep coming back to the sunny kitchen in one and the short walk to work from the other. You’re chewing the cud over the choice. You haven’t necessarily chosen either one.
In the literal sense, cud is food that an animal such as a cow brings back from its stomach to chew again. A cow lying in a field may look as though it’s eating even when it hasn’t taken a fresh bite of grass. University of Minnesota Extension describes cud chewing as part of a cow’s digestion.
The idea of a second chew makes the human meaning easier to remember. A thought you’ve already had comes back for another look. You may notice a detail you missed the first time.
| What happened after the apartment visits? | Which description fits? |
|---|---|
| You read the rent for the first time. | You’re gathering a new fact. |
| You turn the two rents over in your head on the ride home. | You’re chewing the cud. |
| You sign a lease the next morning. | You’ve made a decision. The thinking came before it. |
It can be quiet reflection, or two people can chew the cud together by talking an idea over at length. In “We sat on the porch chewing the cud about the move,” there’s a subject both people keep returning to. Chew the fat usually means chat in a relaxed way, even if nobody is considering a decision.
Ruminate is a more formal verb that also connects cud chewing with thinking something over. Food for thought is the idea that gives you something to consider. Chewing the cud is what you do as you consider it.
In an annotated edition of Shakespeare’s As You Like It, Act IV, scene III, page 119 describes Orlando walking through the forest, “chewing the cud of sweet and bitter fancy.” He is absorbed in his thoughts. That wording is a useful example of the metaphor in print.
Cud rhymes with mud. The verb changes as usual: chews the cud, chewed the cud, chewing the cud. If the image would puzzle your listener, “Let me think it over” is a plain way to ask for time.
Choose an answer to see why it fits or what clue to look for. You can change your answer.
A cow is chewing while lying down away from fresh grass. Which meaning fits?
Pat spent the evening chewing the cud over a job offer. Did Pat accept it?
Two people swap jokes with no particular subject. Which expression fits especially well?
